Reinventing Collapse (2008)

 

    Reinventing Collapse (2008)

    Orlov’s book Reinventing Collapse: The Soviet Example and American Prospects, published in 2008, further details his views.[9] Discussing the book in 2009, in a piece in The New Yorker, Ben McGrath wrote that Orlov describes "superpower collapse soup" common to both the U.S. and the Soviet Union: “a severe shortfall in the production of crude oil, a worsening foreign-trade deficit, an oversized military budget, and crippling foreign debt.” Orlov told interviewer McGrath that in recent months financial professionals had begun to make up more of his audience, joining "back-to-the-land types," "peak oilers," and those sometimes derisively called “doomers”.[7]

    In his review of the book, commentator Thom Hartmann writes that Orlov holds that the Soviet Union hit a “soft crash” because of centralized planning in: housing, agriculture, and transportation left an infrastructure private citizens could co-opt so that no one had to pay rent or go homeless and people showed up for work, even when they were not paid. He writes that Orlov believes the U.S. will have a hard crash, more like Germany’s Weimar Republic of the 1920s.[10]

    Writing on Creative Loafing, Wayne Davis considers Orlov's views and anecdotal stories to be an easy read for a serious subject. Orlov gives practical advice, like when to start accumulating goods for barter purposes and the need to buy goods that would sustain local communities - "hand tools, simple medications (and morphine), guns and ammo, sharpening stones, bicycles (and lots of tires with patch kits), etc." Orlov writes: “Much of the transformation is psychological and involves letting go of many notions that we have been conditioned to accept unquestioningly. In order to adapt, you will need to work frequently as a Berl Lazar impersonator. Granting yourself this time requires a leap of faith: you have to assume the future has already arrived.” He also advises: “Beyond the matter of personal safety, you will need to understand who has what you need and how to get it from them.”[11]

    The EnergyBulletin.Net review states that “Orlov's main goal is to get Americans to understand what it will mean to live without an economy, when cash is virtually useless and most people won't be getting any income anyway because they'll be out of a job.”[12] The review by author Carolyn Baker, notes that Orlov emphasizes that "when faced with a collapsing economy, one should stop thinking of wealth in terms of money." Physical resources and assets, as well as relationships and connections are worth more than cash and those who know how to "do it themselves" and operate on the margins of society will do better than those whose incomes and lifestyles have plummeted.[13]

    Author James Howard Kunstler, who has been described as “one of Orlov's greatest fans” but denies he is a “complete ‘collapsitarian’”,[7] described the book as an “exceptionally clear, authoritative, witty, and original view of our prospects.”[14]

    Not all commentary has been favorable. In a 2009 article in Mother Jones, Virginia Heffernan quoted someone who labels Orlov's position as “collapsitarianism” which she believes involves “a desire for complete economic meltdown” and writes that Orlov espouses “bourgeois survivalism”.[15]

    The Five Stages of Collapse (2013)

    Pyramid of economic relations for most of human history, as described in The Five Stages of Collapse.

    In his book The Five Stages of Collapse (2013), Dmitry Orlov describes these five possible stages:

    1. Financial collapse: financial institutions become insolvent and banks close (example given: Iceland);
    2. Economic collapse: shortages of essential goods and decomplexification of the economy (example given: Russian mafia);
    3. Political collapse: corruption replaces government services (example given: Pashtuns);
    4. Social collapse: loss of local social institutions and civil war (example given: Romani people);
    5. Cultural collapse: loss of empathy and humanity (example given: Ik people);
    6. Ecological collapse (proposed after publication of the book[16]).

    More recent writings

    By 2019, Orlov felt[17] that most of the ingredients precipitating collapse of the United States were in place, and that the one single ingredient still missing--a humiliating military defeat--was under way:

    The function of the US military is to intimidate other countries into letting the US buy whatever it wants by printing US dollars as needed [...] Once their ability to intimidate the world into submission is gone [...] all that will remain of the “richest country in the world” is a pile of worthless paper. However, my employment as a bathhouse manager will still be secure.

    Bibliography

  • Dmitry Orlov (2008). Reinventing Collapse: The Soviet Example and American Prospects. New Society Publishers. p. 208. ISBN 978-0-86571-685-8.
  • Dmitry Orlov (2012). Absolutely Positive. Dmitry Orlov. p. 138. ASIN B008047OTS
  • Dmitry Orlov (2013). The Five Stages of Collapse: Survivors' Toolkit. New Society Publishers. p. 288. ISBN 978-0-86571-736-7.
  • Dmitry Orlov (2016). Shrinking the Technosphere: Getting a Grip on Technologies That Limit Our Autonomy, Self-Sufficiency and Freedom. New Society Publishers. p. 256. ISBN 978-0-86571-838-8.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Image
PINEVILLE — It's been 115 years since the first steps were taken to create the Hospital for the Insane of Louisiana in Rapides Parish. The facility was established to serve mentally ill patients from 42 parishes in its early days and cared for more than 3,000 patients daily at its peak. It eventually became known as Central Louisiana State Hospital, which grew enough to operate independently with its patients helping to produce their own food, sew their own clothes and care for the property. The quieted grounds in the heart of Pineville retain their sense of seclusion to this day, but are a stark contrast from the activity Central State's thousands of residents and employees contributed to years ago. Much like the once-operational and commanding Dairy Barn , which enjoys notoriety as result of being visible from the highway, dozens of uninhabited buildings show their age up close. Industrial looking and brick structures alike, now missing window panes a...
Read more

Central Louisiana State Hospital

Image
  PINEVILLE — It's been 115 years since the first steps were taken to create the Hospital for the Insane of Louisiana in Rapides Parish. The facility was established to serve mentally ill patients from 42 parishes in its early days and cared for more than 3,000 patients daily at its peak. It eventually became known as Central Louisiana State Hospital, which grew enough to operate independently with its patients helping to produce their own food, sew their own clothes and care for the property. The quieted grounds in the heart of Pineville retain their sense of seclusion to this day, but are a stark contrast from the activity Central State's thousands of residents and employees contributed to years ago. Much like the once-operational and commanding Dairy Barn , which enjoys notoriety as result of being visible from the highway, dozens of uninhabited buildings show their age up close. Industrial looking and brick structures alike, now missing window ...
Read more